![]() |
Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
What is in your home defense and CC pistol/revolver? Any personal stories to promote a certain brand and type?
|
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
Any quality hollow point with do. I like Gold Dots, but Remington golden sabers, Winchester silver tips, Hornady XTP's, etc. all work just fine too.
Gelatin testing is usually how performance is evaluated. It is obviously not anything like a human body, no tissue property variations, no rib cage simulation, etc. FBI says 12 inches of penetration in gelatin is what they require. This factors in that they may be engaging bad guys through obstructions, like a window or something. While you or I may not be likely to do that, why not have the ability to in case you need it? anyways, here are some tests and you can find others by just google searching. Lots of gun forums have more info: http://www.brassfetcher.com/ |
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
Quote:
Glock 22 & 35: Speer Gold Dot 165 JHP and 180 JHP Glock 27: Speer Gold Dot 155 JHP Glock 31 & 33: Winchester 125 JHP 357Sig, Speer Gold Dot 125 JHP Glock 19 & 17: Speer Gold Dot 124+P JHP, Winchester Ranger T 124+P and 127+P+ Yes, I like Speer Gold Dot, as well as Winchester Ranger "T" series. SC |
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
Whatever you get, buy a little at first and test it in your gun!!
I bought a box of corbon .45 185 gr JHP's +P. Spent a good chunk of cash on it, come to find out they arent all that accurate with my particular gun(or it could just have been me, but Im not a bad shot). They were bad, but I was getting some big spreads. probably because I was shooting a 185 gr +P out of a 3 inch barrel on a compact gun. Either way, I am going to find another alternative to this ammunition to see if I can get better grouppings, because while they were good, they were "trust your life on it" good. So whatever you get, practice with it! |
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
From the various test, reports and discussons I've read, I like to have Gold Dots, Golden Sabres, XTP's, and Hydro Shocks loaded in my various firearms. No particular order, but since this wasn't multiple choices i picked GD although I think sabres got better performancein some testings but that may have been just one caliber or two.
|
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
Ummmm......where's the choice for
CORBON? http://www.impactguns.com/store/cor_bon_ammo.html EDIT: I'm stupid. I see it. |
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
Federal HST
|
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
I use multiple brands of US-made, high-quality/high-reputation HPs. They all have their personalities, and I won't use anything that doesn't have minimum performance.
Anyone try the new Hornady Critical Defense? |
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
In .45 - Hornady 200 GR +P
In .40 - Hornady 165 GR +P In 9mm - Hydra Shocks (134 GR I think) |
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
Corbon
But i am not opposed to any reliable hollowpoint with good velocity figures |
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
Quote:
:applause_ |
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
Quote:
|
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
And now for the contrarian opinion.
I can't afford to stock up on that fancy stuff and I, like one of the other posters, don't lend much credence to the ballistic gel tests, especially since the STATE OF MIND (or chemical state) of the guy you shoot has so much to do with whether he keeps coming or cries for Mommy. Yes, I understand all the basic physics but the variables are infinite. My choice? Ball. Copper jacketed ball. Simple, reliable, BALL. |
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
My favorite is Winchester Ranger (aka new and more PC Black Talon). It feeds well in all of my guns and has performed well in expansion tests. It's marketed as Law Enforcement only ammo, but can be easily found and purchased by non-LEOs.
|
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
Quote:
|
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
Hornady XTP
Spooky accurate in my CZ82 |
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
Gold Dots have proven themselves for me. XTP's... I have a fair stock of too.
Now, given that I am a reloader, those are my answers as a matter of projectile....cuz that's how it was presented. As a matter of manufacturers, I like Federal and Hornady. |
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
I usually carry Corbon but I have no problem with any of the major brands, Winchester Ranger, Gold Dot, Hornady.
When buying HP defense ammo I buy lighter weight stuff. 9mm - 115 grain, .40 - 165 grain and .45 - 200grain. For SHTF hoarding I buy FMJ. I will not buy lesser known brands no matter what the specs are or what their ads say. and what the heck is Extreme Shock Fang Face? Sounds like something you would buy in Chinatown. |
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
I picked Speer Gold Dot just because I got 1k rounds of it for $260 on gunbroker about a year ago :) It's painfully expensive at the gun store.
|
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
SHOT PLACEMENT!!!
I have an assortment of the stuff listed, in .45ACP, I practice drawing and shooting with Winchester ball ammo. So, per Clint Smith of Thunder Ranch I keep that in my mags. I have shot thousands of rounds thru it with ball, so that's whats in it. No feeding problems, etc. It's about shot placement anyway. |
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
Quote:
|
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
Quote:
|
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
Quote:
:biggrin: |
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
Quote:
:thumb.aspx: |
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
QUOTE: One round of cheapo Wal-Mart Whitebox FMJ in the heart is better then ten rounds of Donald Trump Black Label Platinum Magnum Superduper Geewiz Howitzer Fullest Jacketed Hollowpoint +P in the wallpaper.
Shot placement IS critical. Shot through the heart? A person can remain conscious and return fatal fire for up to 15 seconds after a fatal wound to the heart. You would do better to shoot for the brain. Oh, and good luck with that. Here's a simple test. Try shooting a balloon at 25 yards with a FMJ. By the way, more people are killed with the 22LR than any other cartridge. But, would you carry a 22 pistol for self-defense? |
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
Quote:
While shooting a ballon at 25 yards with ball ammo is a pretty easy feat in the safe environment of the range, 25 yard shootouts with sidearms are pretty rare. We all need to disabuse ourselves of the TV-inspired myth that people who get shot lay down and die within a few seconds. |
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
My point, it is possible to hit a balloon with a 9mm FMJ and not break it. Why handicap yourself with poorer terminal ballistics of a FMJ when your life or the life of your loved ones is on the line?
|
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
I also think round placement is probably one of the most critical factors, along with reliable feeding in semi-automatic pistols. With some firearms, ball is fine; others I prefer JHP.
Springfield GI - 230 grain ball Winchester whitebox. Keltec P32 - 73 grain ball Fiocchi. CZ75 / Hi Power - +P 9mm Federal JHP; practice with Winchester whitebox. Ruger SP101 - Remington 125 grain JHP - I've yet to try 125 Speer Gold Dot. Take care, Mod1 |
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
1 Attachment(s)
Can we agree that JHP is a better defensive bullet then FMJ and that they all expand and get the job done? Wal-Mart JHP at 100/$25 makes more sense then Donald Trump Black Label Platinum Magnum Superduper Geewiz Howitzer Fullest Jacketed Hollowpoint +P at 20/$15. :dontknow: |
Re: Premium self defense ammunition: Your choice?
when the bullit hits the bone . they all work.
|
| All times are GMT -4. The time now is 10:50 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright = None use it and Link to GIM